Ponybooru Collab Image - 2024 Edition

Poll results: What Should This Year's Theme Be?

Las Pegasus Casino
35.56% 16 votes
Moonbase Equestria
22.22% 10 votes
Tribal Island
11.11% 5 votes
Castle Crashers
11.11% 5 votes
Winter Wrap-Up
11.11% 5 votes
Other
6.67% 3 votes
No Theme
2.22% 1 vote

Poll ended with 45 votes.

FeatherTrap
Boot badge - It's Bootiful
Chatty Kirin - A user who has reached a combined 1000 forum posts or comments.
A toast - Incredibly based
Artist -
Liberty Belle - Sings the song of the unchained

Public Relations
Sir Boops-A-Lot
@Twiface
Everyone seems to complain whenever I try tweaking the rules so I’m decided I’m fucking done even trying. I’m not going to be the one compiling this anyway, runner2 is doing that, he can sort this shit out if that’s his prerogative.
I’m going to focus all of my effort into organizing the background and assets with the artist. The assets will include things like chairs, stools, gaming tables and other relevant props that all entries can use. Come to me with questions about that from now on, I’m done trying to sort out the rules. Especially when some people don’t even fucking read them before giving up on this entirely.
runner2
Boot badge - It's Bootiful
Donor | Luna - THE LOVE HAS BEEN DOUBLED!
Artist -
Liberty Belle - Sings the song of the unchained

Public Relations
Libertatem Noctibus
Multiple characters in a single submission as well as multiple submissions should be fine. The only limiting factor will be what the background layout is, but it shouldn’t be too constricting overall. Even if it’s just the handful of us already here throwing characters in it will be fine.
Our second selling point is that we allow more content to be posted here then on Derpi. There’s the obvious one in regards to filly characters of a certain design, but also characters that caused the fracturing of Derpi to begin with (Aryanne for instance). We are more relaxed on posting rules overall here.
runner2
Boot badge - It's Bootiful
Donor | Luna - THE LOVE HAS BEEN DOUBLED!
Artist -
Liberty Belle - Sings the song of the unchained

Public Relations
Libertatem Noctibus
It would probably be best to discuss anything first before coming up with rules out of nowhere about things. Even just openly asking in the forums here or just directly messaging among us that are working on it first would be fine. That way any single person avoids conflict from a rule they put out and they also get to work out how best to implement any rules or to avoid unnecessary ones before rolling them out.
But you can certainly just stick to the background designs and stuff related to that. I can stick to composition of the final thing. Twiface can stick to the more open discussions and general QnA stuff that might pop up. But we can all still discuss whatever might come up overall as well. Just as long as whatever we come up with will be helpful. Otherwise we can just not bother making rules/answers to questions that haven’t been asked yet.
Twiface
Twilight Kirin - A user who has reached a combined 1000 forum posts or comments.
A toast - Incredibly based

Public Relations
Princess of the Moon
@runner2
Since you’re going to be compiling the image, do you have any preferences for what our multiple characters rule should be? I have been insisting that the rule we currently have in place is probably too convoluted for most users to understand and that we should simplify it to just a blanket 4 or 6 character limit and delete the part about character ranking, and I think I’ll go ahead with that unless you object. Do you think that’s reasonable, or would you prefer I do something else?
we can just not bother making rules/answers to questions that haven’t been asked yet.
I think everything we’ve been talking about so far has been based on questions people have asked. Every rule we haven’t discussed is just a rewording of one of last year’s rules.
I have read through these 2 pages multiple times and I’m not sure I understand what’s happening.
Exactly.
@FeatherTrap
I apologize for the frustration I’m causing you.
runner2
Boot badge - It's Bootiful
Donor | Luna - THE LOVE HAS BEEN DOUBLED!
Artist -
Liberty Belle - Sings the song of the unchained

Public Relations
Libertatem Noctibus
I would say go somewhat with how I worded it on the previous page. Don’t really give a limit as there will probably not be a large amount of submissions posted so limiting the already few artists shouldn’t be necessary. Allow them to draw their OCs, their friend’s OCs, community OCs, and just other community member’s OCs. Like I mentioned about if only a few artists want to draw all of the OCs… then I say just let them go for it.
Currently I haven’t seen any submissions at all yet so the more open we are to accepting some, the better. We don’t want it to look empty after all.
However… if we do somehow start getting bombarded with submissions then maybe we could look into a cap per user’s OCs, followed by a per artist cap if it actually begins to get excessive. Combination submissions (with multiple OCs) shouldn’t be bad as long as the spacing between characters is minimal. That also shouldn’t really count against any limits that could be imposed. If we get multiple group submissions, then as long as they are grouped nicely and not too spread out, it should be fine even if it’s by just one or two artists.
Regardless though, it all depends on the scale and layout of the background design and pose/interaction choices. Perhaps limiting specific poses to some degree wouldn’t be bad though. Such as flying characters, slot machine actions (arm or foreleg lifted to pull lever), or game table poses (holding cards, holding/rolling dice, placing bets or interacting with chips on a table. Simple sitting poses, standing poses, or even some basic walking poses really shouldn’t be a problem, so having a lot of them should be fine.
Overall though a lot of this at such an early point in this process will be speculation and blind guessing. I would say just let it play out for a while and then we could step in with limits if we really need to. But unless a lot of the Derpi crowd starts joining in, I really doubt any limits would be needed.
Twiface
Twilight Kirin - A user who has reached a combined 1000 forum posts or comments.
A toast - Incredibly based

Public Relations
Princess of the Moon
I’ve decided to go ahead and make the rule adjustments I said I would (raised the limit to 6, deleted the bits about ranking and an obsolete (and admittedly ill-conceived) one-per-person group submissions rule.
I hope that simplifies and clarifies things. I fear that having a convoluted rule set would scare people away, especially regarding the multiple OC’s rule.
I also added a bit about submissions opening on July 4th (which just happened to be the day when the poll closes; I just set it for seven days) so people know when to begin posting.
The deadline is in September so there’s no rush. I know how busy and hard-to-reach some artists can get.
Twiface
Twilight Kirin - A user who has reached a combined 1000 forum posts or comments.
A toast - Incredibly based

Public Relations
Princess of the Moon
@Deserter
We’re simplifying our character rules and raising the limit to 6. Bring all the Toffy sisters, we’ll fit them in somehow.
Twiface
Twilight Kirin - A user who has reached a combined 1000 forum posts or comments.
A toast - Incredibly based

Public Relations
Princess of the Moon
As the self-appointed County Clerk of Derpibooru County, I hereby announce that polls have officially closed.
And as Derpibooru’s self-appointed Secretary of State, I hereby certify the results of this election.
The Casino will be this year’s theme.
It won by a margin of 6 votes, and I guarantee there were no last-minute ballot dumps.
I really mean it. No new votes came in during the last hour, and I watched that thing like a hawk!
Thank you to everyone who voted, especially to those who chose the correct answer.
(except for that guy who said ‘No Theme.’ Shame on you! >:P )
Anyway, you may now begin submitting characters (we raised the limit to six per user, and they may be added together or individually).
Please remember that transparent backgrounds are required (such as vector images), and should be uploaded with the tag ponybooru collab 2024
Once uploaded to the site, place a link to the image(s) in this thread.
The committee organizing the collab reserves the right to reject any submissions which violate the rules outlined on the front page. Submissions should aim for the Safe tag, but due to this year’s theme we will allow the line to be blurred with suggestive. A blanket ban on AI content has also been implemented, per popular demand on last year’s collab’s thread.
The Deadline to submit characters is to be determined
Though if you submit one a few minutes late we aren’t going to ding you (it might take a few days to compile the image)
And if you have any questions or would like to petition us, feel free to ask anyone with a Public Relations tag for help.
DuskenDraws
Artist -

Public Relations
Does Gay Things
Will we be able to get a sneak peek at what the background image will look like? Might help some people think of certain poses and/or what they can interact with. I guess overall I’m not sure how the idea of someone sitting at a slot machine might play out in practice (if that’s something people are doing)- if the artist draws their own slot machine, or it’s implemented in the background image itself.
Twiface
Twilight Kirin - A user who has reached a combined 1000 forum posts or comments.
A toast - Incredibly based

Public Relations
Princess of the Moon
@DuskenDraws
I’m wondering this as well. I was thinking of commissioning a character operating a table facing a certain way.
At the very least, it would be nice to coordinate a theme for the furniture design so that if people want to provide their own (which I’m considering doing) so that we don’t have wildly different designs for everything.
This might be the most ambitious Community Collab project yet, but if we can successfully pull it off it will be amazing.
runner2
Boot badge - It's Bootiful
Donor | Luna - THE LOVE HAS BEEN DOUBLED!
Artist -
Liberty Belle - Sings the song of the unchained

Public Relations
Libertatem Noctibus
I was kinda hoping that all furniture and other assets would be separate from the background entirely. That way I can add any assets as needed rather then being stuck with a set layout with either too many or too few characters to fill those spots.
Of course having some empty slots, chairs, or tables wouldn’t be out of the question just to either fill in some empty spaces or simply make the area look more proper.
Depending on the overall turnout this could either look like the Las Pegasus type of casino or potentially a more mundane/simple one being from Ponyville or the like. Mostly depending on how the style of the background is and what I have to work with in regards to that.
Hericks

@FeatherTrap
I don’t think anyone is expecting to see the completed background and assets
more just asking about a rough doodle of the basic layout, or a couple layout ideas, in order to plan on how to orient characters.
(Like a circle labeled “stage area” and squares with arrows to show angles of slot machines, something like that)
I’d say this whole thing is still in the planning stage. After all, the theme was JUST decided on…
Two months isn’t too bad of a time frame, but yeah, I can see where you’re coming from.. that date is gonna come up quicker than one would expect… the ball will have to get rolling pretty quick…
Twiface
Twilight Kirin - A user who has reached a combined 1000 forum posts or comments.
A toast - Incredibly based

Public Relations
Princess of the Moon
Take your time with everything. We aren’t in a hurry to finish it. I just extended the deadline by seven hours, and I could always push it back further.
I just think that having a deadline will motivate us to complete it within a reasonable amount of time, and prevent this project from being forgotten about and abandoned.
Also, which day is your birthday on?
FeatherTrap
Boot badge - It's Bootiful
Chatty Kirin - A user who has reached a combined 1000 forum posts or comments.
A toast - Incredibly based
Artist -
Liberty Belle - Sings the song of the unchained

Public Relations
Sir Boops-A-Lot
@Twiface
I mean heck, it might just take us that long to track down the thought criminal who voted “no theme” and execute them for treason in Minecraft!
For legal reasons, I need to specify that was intended as a joke, I am not being serious about actually hunting someone down and doing/inciting harm for picking a valid option in a poll that we set up ourselves, okay Australian Police? Go find a gangland shooter or child molester to arrest ffs, do your actual fuckin’ job.
Sometime this month, wild mystery date…
Twiface
Twilight Kirin - A user who has reached a combined 1000 forum posts or comments.
A toast - Incredibly based

Public Relations
Princess of the Moon
@FeatherTrap
There were also at least two^*^ people who said ‘other’ and didn’t specify what they would rather have.
*I suspect one of those three people may have been the one who wanted the “Pooh’s Adventures” style crossover with dinosaurs.
Alrighty then. I was going to say ‘happy birthday’ on your actual birthday, but if you don’t reveal it between now and the 31st then I will just do it on the 31st.
Twiface
Twilight Kirin - A user who has reached a combined 1000 forum posts or comments.
A toast - Incredibly based

Public Relations
Princess of the Moon
@BenPictures1
Well, let’s check the rules:
(alternate interpretations of canon characters, such as Raptorshy, are allowed if sufficiently different from the canon OC to be distinguishable).
Which was me trying to parahprase last year’s semi-canon OCs rule:
No canon characters, at least not as the main focus of the image; kinda defeats the purpose (plushies and merch are allowed). We haven’t decided how we feel about semi-OCs (i.e. original/alternate interpretations of canon characters) yet. We might have to decide on a case by case basis (for instance, “fluttershy but she’s raptor” would be allowed, while “Lyra in a tux” wouldn’t count as an OC)
We will consider “a corrupted version of Sunset” if we think it is sufficiently different enough from regular Sunset.
FeatherTrap
Boot badge - It's Bootiful
Chatty Kirin - A user who has reached a combined 1000 forum posts or comments.
A toast - Incredibly based
Artist -
Liberty Belle - Sings the song of the unchained

Public Relations
Sir Boops-A-Lot
As the self-appointed Minister of Tempering Expectations and Steadying-On, I hereby announce that our local self-appointed County Clerk of Derpibooru County, Secretary of State, and Moon Princess impressionist has jumped the gun by quite a margin here. So to avoid a mad scramble, allow me to assuage concerns with the following official announcement:
There will be ABSOLUTELY NO OFFICIAL DEADLINE ANNOUCEMENT until the background is ready and the vector assets (chairs, tables, bar stools, etc.) are made available to all users.
Please forgive the weird brainfart-salad that this thread has turned into, this is the first time we’re organising this event, there was a little bit of feature/scope creep and it’s become a small portion of pure madness as a result.
But; the good news is that we’re gradually solidifying into something coherent and consistent and we’re determined to finish this project.
In order to do that however, we need to stop being overly optimistic and excitable with setting “official deadlines! TM” for the sake of having reasonable expectations of the time we’re all asking of our community members and artists who will be drawing people’s submissions. Unless I’ve greatly misread the situation and the mafia will murder my fellow volunteers if they don’t see casino ponies before Spoopy-Month, then I see absolutely no reason for the mad insistence of “It neds turr be dun bi SEPTEMBHUUUUURRRRRR!!
We haven’t even started this project until Late June, the scope of the collab is much larger then normal (requiring an entirely new background and assets commissioned specifically for this event) and it’s being run by random users from the community who have to do this while managing their day jobs. Consequently, this is going to take us longer then normal and that’s okay. A Collab delayed for the sake of making the best quality picture is eventually good, a Collab rushed for the sake of saying we can do this on a DB timescale will be bad forever.
I’m already not happy with how soon we even had this poll anyway. if Mr. Moon Prince of the Exchequer, or indeed anypony at all had actually consulted me about it first, I would have preferred to have had a display of all five of the originally suggested themes available for viewing before we even began to vote-and that includes at least two suggestions for “on theme” clothing/outfits for people who couldn’t think of what they wanted their ponies to wear to the event.
But setting official dates and getting that link at the top of the page is just so exciting, isn’t it so here we are now, after asking everyone to vote on it completely blind. XP
Rest assured, that next year I will be imposing a strict “no poll until all themes are ready for appraisal” rule so this mess doesn’t happen again.
Regardless, being a passive-aggressive little shit about things isn’t helpful so I shan’t indulge myself in snark any further, typing this post has served as suitable catharsis anyway. What I ask my fellow volunteers now is that we need to be closer with communication and have a cohesive vision for the project. I hate to suggest some kind of private Discord chat or something of that nature as I’d prefer that all the discussions and updates about rules be 100% transparent and available to the public. But this thread over the last week has been an absolute fucking mess and an insult to the very concept of organisation and co-ordination so we need some way of making sure we’re all working on the same page and with the same itinerary lest we start having fights in the threads over what the rules and standards of our own project should be. If a private Discord chat is the lesser evil in this regard then we need to grit our teeth and bare it.
So again, just to re-iterate:
There is currently NO OFFICIAL DEADLINE FOR SUBMISSIONS. Deadline to be determined at a later date when WE ACTUALLY HAVE A COLLAB TO ASSEMBLE.
Thank y’all for your time. ^^
Syntax quick reference: **bold** *italic* ||hide text|| `code` __underline__ ~~strike~~ ^sup^ %sub%

Detailed syntax guide