Character that were nominated but didn’t managed to get in(from canon, fandom OCs and exclusive /mlp/ memes) and the score they got  
Blackjack 85  
Ms. Peachbottom 85  
Appointed Rounds 84  
Pipp Petals 82  
Screwloose 81  
Lighthoof 81  
Sunny Delivery 80  
Apple Bumpkin 80  
Lady Amalthea 80  
Gilda 78  
MRE / Mares Ready to Eat 75  
Stompy Slippers 75  
Princess Erroria 74  
Adagio Dazzle 74  
Pine Ponder 74  
Apple Cobbler 73  
Gabby 73  
Mannequin 72  
Gloomy Sonnet 72  
Burning Passion 71  
Wallflower Blush 71  
Posey Bloom 71  
Raggie 70  
Bait Pony 70  
Zephyr 70  
Wind Sprint 68  
Almond Joy 68  
Ember 68  
Sphinx 67  
Granny Smith 66  
Pizza Pony 66  
Clementine 66  
Screwball 65  
Violet Twirl 63  
Spirit of Hearth’s Warming Yet To Come 61 (*Unverified as an Alt, ineligible)  
Noi 61  
Coke Pony 60  
Marker 60  
Fluffle Puff 59  
Rumble Joke Suggestion Anon 58  
Holly Dash 57  
Veronika 57  
Queen Haven 57  
Bright Morning 56  
Tolerance 55  
Glide 55  
Lilac 55  
Firefly 55  
Peep 54  
Arizona 54  
Kiristine Daae 53  
Twilight Glimmer 53 (*Unverified as an Alt, ineligible)  
Minty 52  
Miss Eri 51  
Aria Blaze 51  
Silverstream 51  
Ocellus 51  
Treelight Sparkle 50 (*Unverified as an Alt, ineligible)  
Posey, 50  
Megan Williams 50  
Wind Whistler 50  
Bright Eyes 48  
River Swirl 47  
Whoa Nelly 46  
Yona 46  
Jazz 46  
Smolder 45  
Milky Way (G1) 45  
Pumpkin Cake (Adult) 44 (*Unverified as an Alt, ineligible)  
Shinespark 42  
Princess Skystar 42  
Windy, 42  
Potion Nova 41  
Dahlia 41  
Gimme Moore 40  
Paprika 40  
Zoom Zephyrwing 40  
Posada 39  
Radiant Hope 38  
Slowlight Sparkle 38 (*Unverified as an Alt, ineligible)  
Pumpkin Cake, 37  
Flare Warden 37  
Bundle Joy 36  
Twilight Pie 36 (*Unverified as an Alt, ineligible)  
Gloriosa Daisy 36  
Deathlight 36  
Queen Opaline 36  
Phyllis Cloverleaf 35  
Kalianne 33  
Rarity (EG) 32 (*Unverified as an Alt, ineligible)  
Snowball 32  
Hexferry 31  
Sour Sweet 29  
Flare 29  
Lynn 28  
Starlight Glimmer (EG) 25 (*Unverified as an Alt, ineligible)  
Sickle 22  
Bluebird 22  
Twinkler 22  
Glittery Skater 21