Her unique makeup creates a vast contrast to other mares like Zap-Apple Jam, whom despite her own contrasts plays to her strengths and is a very productive synchronized mare that works well with herself despite her contrasts. Sunbutter on the other hand just isn’t able to do such. As much as the framing was built to have both Pinkie and Sunset share influence, the pink mare as the Impossibility she is practically runs unopposed by her other half. Sunset unable to do anything to restrain or manage the other half of them. Chaos rains supreme in her makeup. Only until she and Zap-Apple fused into Motherly Morning was there enough mares to constrain and restrict pinkie from further control.
Until then, this unstable fusion spends her time mostly baking in private and raving on about ridiculous things while every so often calming down and appearing timid and quiet in an attempt to relax. Such is Sunbutter Cookies.